ArohaMuzic All articles
Opinion

I Read the Setlist Three Weeks Early and I'd Do It Again

ArohaMuzic
I Read the Setlist Three Weeks Early and I'd Do It Again

Photo: sillygwailo, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The ticket was bought in March. The show is in April. It's currently March 12 and I have a browser tab open with a setlist from a city I have never been to, in a venue I will never see, and I am reading it the way other people read the closing minutes of a game they recorded.

I know the opener. I know the closer. I know that song they've been rotating in at slot four. I know there's an encore and I know roughly how long it lasts. I know all of it, and I am going to have an incredible time.

This is, apparently, controversial.

The Tab I Never Close

Look, setlist tracking isn't a fringe hobby anymore. It's a whole ecosystem. Somebody in the crowd types the songs into their phone in real time, and by the time the house lights come up in Columbus, a fan in Sacramento knows what's coming in three weeks. There are people who maintain spreadsheets. There are people who can tell you which night of the tour the band swapped in the deep cut, and which city got it, and how the crowd reacted. It is genuinely impressive archival work performed for free, at 11:40 p.m., by someone standing behind a very tall guy.

And every time I mention that I check, someone tells me I'm ruining it for myself.

What Spoilers Actually Buy You

Here's my counterargument, and it's boringly practical: knowing the setlist makes me a better audience member.

I stop spending the first four songs trying to figure out what the band is doing and start actually listening to it. I know when to be quiet. I know that the third song is the one where the whole room sings and I should not be mid-sentence about parking. I know which song is the new one that everybody's going to politely tolerate, and I can decide to pay attention to it instead of treating it as an intermission.

There's also the small matter of expectations. If I know the band is playing a 19-song set that leans hard into the last two records, I'm not going to spend the night quietly grieving a song from 2014. I'll have made peace with it in the car. That's not efficiency for its own sake — that's clearing space in my own head so the actual show can land somewhere.

And I'll say the thing nobody wants to admit: preparation is a form of love. I learn the words to the songs I don't know yet. I pull up the record I skipped. I show up already inside the material instead of waiting for the room to teach it to me.

The Artists Are Complicated About It

Bands have wildly different relationships with this. Some of them built their whole career on a fixed setlist and treat it like a theater run — same show, every city, delivered at the highest possible level. Others treat a leaked setlist as an act of aggression and will change songs out of spite, or because they saw the list on the internet and felt a little naked.

Then there are the artists who actively weaponize it. Springsteen's been taking sign requests for decades, which is a way of handing the setlist to the crowd and saying "your problem now." Taylor Swift built a whole era around nightly surprises that made spoiler culture feel like part of the show — half the fun was the group chat refreshing at 10:47 p.m. to find out what got played.

That's the part the anti-spoiler crowd misses. Bands aren't dumb. They know you know. Some of them have started writing sets with the knowledge that a certain segment of the room is waiting for one specific song, and they'll place it at slot twelve, and they'll watch the room detonate. The spoiler is now a tool in the arrangement.

The Case for Going In Blind

The blind-going people have one genuinely great argument and I want to give it its due.

Surprise is a physical sensation. When a band drops into a song you did not expect, your body reacts before your brain catches up — the involuntary whoop, the grab of a stranger's arm. You cannot manufacture that. You can't pre-load it. And the more you study, the more of the night becomes a checklist you're executing rather than an experience you're having.

I've had those nights. The best show I saw this year, I knew nothing going in — I got dragged along, I didn't know the record, and the fifth song hit me so hard I had to look down at my shoes and breathe. If I'd read the setlist, I would've been ready for it. Being ready for it would've been worse.

So the honest position isn't "always spoil" or "never spoil." It's that they're two different shows. One is a reunion with something you've been looking forward to. The other is an ambush. Both are worth attending.

What the Setlist Can't Tell You

Which is why I still go, and why I still check, and why I'm not apologizing for the tab.

The setlist is a program, not the performance. It tells you the songs. It does not tell you that the bass player is going to break a string and the band is going to fill four minutes with something unreleased and gorgeous. It doesn't tell you the room is going to go quiet in a way that feels like a held breath. It doesn't tell you the closer will run long, or that the singer will forget the second verse and laugh about it, or that a guy near the front will hold up a sign that changes the whole night.

I know the setlist. I don't know the show. That's the entire difference, and it's a big enough difference to build a night around.

See you in April. I'll be the one singing every word, including the ones I only learned two weeks ago.

All Articles

Related Articles

The 7:45 Problem: Ranking Every Slot on a Four-Band Bill

The 7:45 Problem: Ranking Every Slot on a Four-Band Bill

The Vault Has a Door: Why Indie Bands Are Keeping Their Best Songs Off Streaming

The Vault Has a Door: Why Indie Bands Are Keeping Their Best Songs Off Streaming

Say It Wrong, Love It Anyway: The Case for Falling for Bands You Can't Pronounce

Say It Wrong, Love It Anyway: The Case for Falling for Bands You Can't Pronounce